
Ugh, what have we started?
With two bowsers and allergens abounding in Austin, for sinus survival, our wall-to-wall Berber had to go. We didn’t have the $ resources to hire a crew to de-carpet the house, so my husband & I decided to wing it ourselves. Our ultimate goal was to end up with shiny concrete floors that wouldn’t hug pollen and spores and who knows what else. We did it! Here’s the play-by-play:
The scope of our project:
The entire main floor of Casa Przybylinski (other than kitchen & bathroom) was carpeted with allergen hugging Berber loops when we purchased the home in 2004. By 2006, having mustered my way through 3 sinus surgeries, my husband & I knew the Berber had to go.
General budget?:
After paying over $20,000 out of pocket for medical bills that our insurance carrier chalked up to deductibles, our general budget was merely a piggy bank. Piggy squealed when we peeked at wood, laminate or tile floors. Even getting a contractor to do the staining job was out of our reach: we received average quotes of $4000.
To get the job done, and silence the squealer, we figured that if we researched staining pre-carpeted concrete floors on the web, we could pull up the Berber carpet and stain our dining room, bedroom, hallways, and living room by ourselves for about $500.
How close did we land on budget?
We stayed under budget by doing all the work ourselves and returning any unused (unopened) product to respective stores (we hung on to those receipts like a ribbon won at field days). Examples of product that we were able to return; initially we were quoted needing 5 gallons of stain to adequately cover 1000 sqft. Quality (fresh) stain runs $60 a gallon, so right out of the starting gate we plunked down $360 for stain. {I added on one more gallon as I graduated from the school of “More is Better.”} But, by preparing the floors well, and mixing the stain as directed 1 to 1 with water, we were able to return 4 gallons of stain unused and recouped $240.
$ for $, the best money spent was:
The money on the stain was the best money spent—it was fresh, and absolutely the right brew of penetrating reactive stain that beautifully combined with our freshly cleaned concrete. We used BAS-14 “Cordovan Leather” from Butterfield Color. It’s available to the public by a great concrete firm (super personable & helpful employees) on St. Elmo across from the City Hazardous Waste Center. How convenient.
$ for $, money that was not well spent?
A paint sprayer that we purchased at a local hardware store was a clunker—because you can’t use metal when working with acid stain, we searched high and low for a sprayer that did not have a metal wand. We finally found a sprayer with a vinyl hose, hurrah! But when we got it home, a clunk sounded in the box and we instantly realized the uptake section of the hose was metal. Worthless for this project, and the store would not take it back.
We didn’t waste time with haggling—we were on a compressed time schedule—it was Memorial Day weekend, monsoon humid rains were coming and our 2 dogs were raking up the meter at the kennel and surely shaking with each thunder boom while we transformed the floors. Just knowing how uncomfortable Mr. Dooley & Dusty (our family hounds) must have been with storms over furry heads and unfamiliar grounds under furry paws made us work feverishly with our own furry paws to get the job done and get them home.

Can we come in yet? Hurry up already...
We went back to several home improvement stores looking for a proper sprayer without success, so we pulled a MacGyver and bought two wooden mop poles (without metal screws) and duct-taped (Garrison Keeler would love us) lambs wool window cleaning thingies to the poles, dipped the contraptions into a commercial rolling bucket and proceeded to stain our floors in great sweeps of color. Hint: you know that you have prepared your floors correctly if the stain turns a shocking fluorescent chartreuse foamy color as soon as connects with the concrete. The stain mellows in a few hours to the chosen color—again, in our case, Cordovan Leather.
If we had it to do over:
I would have whispered incantations over the piggy bank (and/or put my hair in a pony, jumped out of a bottle and blinked for extra cash) in order to hire a crew to come in and help with the initial floor preparations.
When pulling up carpet in an 18 year old home that was built in the crazy “build ‘em fast” housing boom in Austin, there was no hint of what we might find underneath in terms of the shape of the concrete.
Thankfully, the concrete was smooth as our piggies flank, but the project was almost doomed from the start due to the plethora of paint, compound, and swiggly glue from the rug in staging areas in each room (including an apparent spilled can of varnish that a contractor walked through…I know his shoe size and have memorized the tread of his boot.)
In order for the stain to permeate the concrete, we had to clean every speck of paint/glue/compound from the flooring. At first inspection, we were ready to throw in the towel. Instead, we got on our hands & knees and many towels for 5 days and tried every cleaner (starting with less toxic) and kept fans circulating and windows opened. Simple Green worked the best. Oh, slide back on one of those towels for a minute—it must be like childbirth, how fast we forget the pain—before cleaning could start, all the tacking strips that held the carpet down into the concrete had to be removed.
My husband & I tried screwdrivers hammered under sections of strip, but that method was way too arduous (though it did create some awesome sparks!) Julie Nelson, a great realtor in Austin, graciously lent us a floor scrapper on a pole (for leverage) and I admit I took great pleasure in whamming that scrapper under the tacking strips. It pulled up a few satisfying lengths, but still too slow. So we bought a new sharp edged shovel (I had cracked the handle on our previous one), and by using my considerable weight and force, the tack strips finally started flying up—complete with chunks of concrete. I figured we would deal with those concrete holes later—I would not look up until I completed an entire room wall, and then my husband would take a turn. Such focus!
Some advice:
Wear a baseball hat during this project. Not just to protect your hair, but to act somewhat like horse-blinders. Keeping your head down and working on one section of floor at a time (completing that section before moving to another) was our saving grace in completing the job. If we had popped our heads up and fully realized the “miles of work” ahead of us, I think our floors would still be left undone.
Have a clean place to rest each evening during the project. Thankfully, we have a 2 story home and were able to climb the stairs into a warm shower and clean sheets each night.
Make sure that you don’t stain yourself out of the house; e.g. if the cold beverages are in kitchen fridge—make sure that entrance way is clear and unlocked. I can’t tell you how many times we’d forget and lock the door and find ourselves biding our time parched on the front porch while the May rains pounded down.
Did we have a contractor, plumber, electrician, innocent bystander who deserved an oscar for best performance?
Best performance in a documentary probably goes to the next door neighbor’s kids faces when they poked their little noggins into the garage to see what we were up to for the long weekend. We were suited in gas-like respirator masks, full length plastic gloves, professional wrap around eye goggles, and baby boomer mutant ninja turtle kneepads. As I was not in the mood to whip off my gear to give a lovely lecture on why Mrs Przybylinski was looking like a transformer, needless to say, those kids skedaddled but quickly.
Next on our list?
Replacing the gold frames around sliding mirror doors in master bath—perhaps with sleek wood; putting some film on the acres of mirror, and figuring out a way to inexpensively replace our gold framed shower stall with a sleek frameless one—like an epoxied terrarium. (Not that I want plants to grow in my shower—nothing green or black there, please!) How hard could that be? Perhaps we could use some auto glass from the salvage yard… And also plan on painting the 80’s gold sink fixtures with some spiffy stainless steel (ok, brushed nickel-ish) paint. No concrete sinks for this chickie.
Happy staining. Give a holler with any questions…Patti P.
UPDATE: April 1, 2011 finally some “after” staining pics

dust mop and use "future" acrylic for shine (can use this wax 8 times then need to remove with vinegar and start fresh again)







February 18, 2010 at 4:07 pm
thank you so much for your comments. Already ripped up carpet. going to buy Simple Green right now. Already spoke w. their technical folks – very helpful.
September 30, 2010 at 6:11 pm
Love your article!!!
We plan on doing the same to our entire first floor. Just have one question for you… do you have pictures of the finished product? I’d like some motivation here…
THank you,
Cindy
April 1, 2011 at 2:12 pm
Do you have any pictures of the finished project? I was going to do laminate flooring after getting rid of my carpet but the concrete stain looks wonderful.
April 1, 2011 at 3:30 pm
Hi Jessica, Cindy & Allie & all,
Thanks for reading the article and thanks for your patience with this reply.
I’ll post the “after” pics in a few minutes, and I’m glad you asked to see them. After living on the stained concrete floors with two dogs with 20 nails for two years, we still love the floors, but if we were in the process of getting house ready for resale, we’d go the laminate or bamboo floor route.
Why? The DIY stained concrete has been a life saver for us (I’m allergic to 13 allergens in the Austin area and the carpet was harboring those criminals). It’s cool on the feet on days like today (almost 90 outside) and is easy to clean.
But, the finish is rustic–guests love it, we love it, but the floor doesn’t look totally finished (divots from concrete patch are hard to blend). We bought bullnosed tile ($300) to lay around the edges of the fireplace tile and entry tile, but have still not installed for fear it will make the floor look too outlined.
So. If you need nice healthy floor and can live with rustic look, go for the stain job. If you are getting house ready to sell, I’d invest in the laminate if you have the $.
Whew. Thanks again for reading. All my best, Patti P.
June 20, 2011 at 2:26 pm
Did you use a rotary scrubber to clean concrete first?
June 20, 2011 at 2:46 pm
Hi Melissa,
Thanks for visiting… we did not use a rotary scrubber to clean the concrete first, but I would if I had a “next time”! We scrubbed by hand (ugh). Rotary scrubber sounds like a great idea. Best of luck to you on your floors. Let us know how they turn out. p.s. interesting…was reading real estate listings yesterday, and one house had laminate floors with stained concrete underneath–the Realtor suggested in her flyer that the laminate would be easy to remove. So that’s good news… concrete floors (at least in Austin) appear to be more desirable than laminate. Woo hoo!
July 20, 2011 at 4:52 pm
Hi Patti,
Great post, and timely too. Well for me at least, as we are going to be doing this too soon. A leaking master shower that soaked the berber in the master closet is pushing us into start mode, lol. Unfortunately, found some paint and plaster over-spray in there so expecting it throughout the rest of the house.
Really enjoyed your writing style, hope you blog some more.
BTW, another Austinite by way of New England, Massachusetts, got here in ’97.
July 20, 2011 at 6:54 pm
Howdy right around the corner, Tim! Soaked Berber is a jungle waiting to happen in Austin. Glad to hear you’re in start mode. You’ll love the results of your (through the over-spray) work!
And thanks for your kind words! I write in several places (most with more regularity than this site) and have great intentions of blending all into one blog. I’ll keep you posted on the merger and would love it if you keep us posted on your floor project.
with kind regards,
patti p.
October 15, 2011 at 7:08 pm
Your floors look pretty nice in your pictures. Wondering if how many applications of the stain you used? What kind of sealant did you use?
We live in a Dayton, Ohio suburb. Our house is a ranch on a slab built in the 60′s. We have three dogs and I’m very tired of vacuuming 2-4 times a day to TRY to stay ahead of the dirt and dog hair. We’ve also got an ugly, outdated and stained linoleum in our kitchen and laundry area. Since the kitchen, living room and main hall blend into each other, I feel like we have to do them all and probably should do them all at the same time to get the same look throughout the entire space.
I stumbled on your experience with staining concrete floors in an effort to find more information about it. I’m afraid to tackle this project because I can’t get on my knees any more. We don’t have any money left either so concrete stained floors seem a great solution to the problem. I figure even if it comes out poorly, we can still get area rugs and when we can afford it, the floors would be ready for either carpet or laminate if we really can’t handle the concrete.
Did you happen to consider or try applying the stain with a broom, rag or mop? Wondering what you think of those options for application because they are the manufacturers recommended application methods on the stains we’ve seen so far.
November 21, 2011 at 2:03 pm
Hi Chris,
Sorry it has taken me so long to get back to you. We used a lambswool mitt ducktaped to a pole to apply the stain–so this is kind of like a mop. I think we had more control with the mitt (rather than a string mop), but I do like your idea of a broom. That may result in cool texture. And I love your attitude! i.e. if it doesn’t work to your absolute liking, your idea of area rugs is great! Best of luck to you. And Happy Thanksgiving!
Patti P.
February 11, 2012 at 1:05 pm
Hello Patti,
Your floors look great! One question I had was whether or not you found it necessary to lower the base boards after removing the carpet? Seems there would be somewhat of a gap between the bare concrete and the bottom of the base boards…thanks
February 11, 2012 at 2:55 pm
Howdy Jason. Thanks for the good floor words!
To answer your question, no, we did not have to lower the base boards after removing the carpet…it was tight in most places though there is a minimal gap between the concrete and bottom of base boards along one wall in the dining room.
If your baseboards were added BEFORE carpet was installed, chances are there will be no gap for you. If the baseboards were added AFTER the carpet was installed, you will probably have to lower the base boards. I hope you have no gap! Thanks again for reading and commenting. Keep me posted on your project. Thanks Jason, Patti P. Austin, TX